| Possession | Shots (on target) | Corners |
| 36% 64% | (10) 14 9 (6) | 1 5 |
 | Shots 14 9 Corners 1 5 Shots on target 10 6 Possession 36 64 Shots off target 4 3 | |
 | The referee whistles for the end of the match | |
| 90' +6 |  | Red Card for Tom Edwards (NY Red Bulls) |
| 90' +6 | | Red Card for Maxi Morález (New York City FC) |
| 90' +3 |  | Cameron Harper (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
| 90' +1 |  | NY Red Bulls: Cameron Harper provided the assist for the goal! |
| 90' +1 |  | |
| 84' |  | NY Red Bulls: Steven Sserwadda(in) - Luquinhas(out) |
| 83' | | NY Red Bulls: Cameron Harper(in) - Dylan Nealis(out) |
| 77' | | Dylan Nealis (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
| 73' | | New York City FC: Chris Gloster(in) - Malte Amundsen(out) |
| 73' | | NY Red Bulls: Omir Fernandez(in) - Lewis Morgan(out) |
| 70' 2-0 | | |
| 64' | | New York City FC: Talles Magno(in) - Santiago Rodríguez (out) |
| 63' | | NY Red Bulls: Patryk Klimala(in) - Tom Barlow(out) |
| 63' | | New York City FC: Maxi Morález(in) - Gabriel Pereira(out) |
| 62' | | Red Card for Thiago Andrade (New York City FC) |
| 56' | | Cristian Cásseres (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
| 52' 1-0 | | |
| 52' | | NY Red Bulls: Aaron Long provided the assist for the goal! |
 | 2nd half begins | |
 | The 1st half ends | |
| 35' | | Aaron Long (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
| 20' | | Malte Amundsen (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
| 18' | | Santiago Rodríguez (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
| 15' | | Keaton Parks (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
 | The match begins | |
| 1' | | Poll Results Who will win this game? NY Red Bulls: 53% Draw: 7% New York City FC: 40% |
