| Total | Matches | Wins | Draws | Losses | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 317 | 113 | (36%) | 51 | (16%) | 153 | (48%) |
| Home | 158 | 53 | (34%) | 24 | (15%) | 81 | (51%) |
| Away | 159 | 60 | (38%) | 27 | (17%) | 72 | (45%) |
| Item | Competition | Home | Away | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Biggest home win | Northern Division One South-East 2018/19 | Carlton Town | 5-0 | Gresley Rovers |
| Northern Division One East 2023/24 | Carlton Town | 5-0 | Bridlington Town | |
| NPL Division One South | Carlton Town | 5-0 | Romulus | |
| Biggest away win | Northern Division One East 2022/23 | Shildon AFC | 0-4 | Carlton Town |
| Worst away defeat | Northern Division One South-East 2018/19 | Frickley Athletic | 6-0 | Carlton Town |
| Worst home defeat | Northern Division One South-East 2018/19 | Carlton Town | 2-6 | Pontefract Collieries |
| Northern League South-East Division One 2019/20 | Carlton Town | 0-4 | Leek Town | |
| Northern Division One South-East 2018/19 | Carlton Town | 0-4 | Stamford | |
| Northern Division One South-East 2018/19 | Carlton Town | 1-5 | Cleethorpes Town |
